Skip to content

Greater Pine Island

Local shops

Shop local — gift shops, boutiques, markets, galleries, bait & tackle and specialty stores across Greater Pine Island.

Run a local shop? List it →

When

Browse by type

Filter by area

Gifts & souvenirs

Cw Fudge Factory LLC

Matlacha

Today: 10 AM – 8 PM

Art & gallery

Island Flair Gallery Boutique

Matlacha

Today: 10 AM – 5 PM

Gifts & souvenirs

Matlacha Menagerie

Matlacha

Today: 10 AM – 5 PM

Event venue

The Venue at Matlacha

Opening Nov 13

One-of-a-kind waterfront art gallery and creative destination featuring original artwork from talented local artists, immersive exhibits, special events, live music, workshops, and unforgettable coastal experiences.

Matlacha

Outdoors & marine

D & D Matlacha Bait and Tackle Inc

Matlacha

Today: 6 AM – 9 PM

Apparel & boutique

Island Time Fashion

Matlacha

Art & gallery

Lovegrove Studio's Matlacha

Matlacha

Today: Closed

Market & grocery

Matlacha Mini Mart

Opening Nov 15

Coming soon to Matlacha — snacks, drinks and ice. Opening date TBA.

Matlacha

Gifts & souvenirs

Matlacha Post Office Gallery & Gifts

Matlacha

Today: 8:30 AM – 4:30 PM

Market & grocery · Gifts & souvenirs

Ol' Banyan Mercantile

Opening Nov 1

COMING SOON -- OPENING DATE TBA! The main building will be home to a Gift Shop with a little bit of something extra from me! There will be limited seating available INSIDE AND OUTSIDE and I will be serving up some familiar favorites throughout the week 🦀 🥧 Fresh pie slices daily 🚚 Permanent pie order pick up location 🥣 Capt’n Con’s Seafood Chowder 🥪 Light lunch options during the week (menu TBA) 🌴 And we’re bringing back Mom’s famous “Where The Hell Is Bokeelia?” tees — with an updated look!

MatlachaBased in Cape Coral

Market & grocery

Pine Island Seafood Company

Retail fish market, not a restaurant — they own the boats, so the catch comes straight off their own fleet. Local Gulf fish, shrimp, blue crab and seasonal stone crab, plus house-smoked fish and seafood dips. Formerly Barnhill Seafood.

Matlacha

Today: 9 AM – 5 PM

Gifts & souvenirs

Trader's Hitching Post

Matlacha

Today: Closed